Judge dismisses terrorism charge against Luigi Mangione in UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson murder case

[media-credit name=”Benjamin B Braun/Post-Gazette” width=1600 align=”center”][/media-credit]

A New York judge has dismissed the state terrorism charges against Luigi Mangione, though the broader murder indictment tied to the death of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson remains.

Mangione, 27, faces a pair of prosecutions—one at the state level and one in federal court—and has pleaded not guilty on all counts. The state case included charges of first-degree murder and allegations that the killing was “an act of terrorism”, which carries life in prison under New York state law.

In hearings held this week, Mangione’s legal team argued that the state and federal cases significantly overlap and that pursuing both constitutes double jeopardy. They also pushed for the dismissal of the terrorism count, contending that the evidence does not support the claim he intended to terrorise a civilian population.

The court agreed to toss out the terrorism enhancement at the state level, though the murder charge stays. Meanwhile, federal charges—which include interstate stalking with possible death penalty exposure—are progressing independently.

The decision marks a major shift in the legal landscape for the case. By removing the terrorism label under state law, public prosecutors lose one of their more severe tools. However, the core allegation—murder of Thompson—will still be adjudicated. Observers say the case intensifies debates over how terrorism statutes are applied and the balance between state and federal prosecutions.

---